Sunday, June 23, 2024
HomeBaseballWoe Be to the Catcherless

Woe Be to the Catcherless

Nathan Ray Seebeck-USA TODAY Sports activities

You’ve already heard it from me. You’ve already heard it from lots of people. You’re going to maintain listening to all of it offseason. This can be a powerful 12 months for groups that wish to add offensive firepower in free company. Until you’re actually into Cody Bellinger or Matt Chapman, it’s Shohei Ohtani or bust, and in keeping with my math, there are 30 groups and just one Ohtani.

That’s a bleak actuality, however it paints with too broad of a brush. That description makes it sound like each group who wants a hitter to play wherever is in equally dire straits. That’s not true, although. If you happen to’re searching for a 3rd baseman or a righty energy bat with questionable defensive worth, you might have choices. If you wish to signal an intriguing younger nook outfielder who may pay dividends just a few years down the street, Jung-hoo Lee is a stable selection. However in case you’re searching for a catcher – sorry, pal, nothing to see right here.

Yearly is a foul 12 months free of charge agent catchers. Within the final 5 years, three catchers have hit the open market after a 3-plus WAR season or its 2020 equal: J.T. Realmuto, James McCann, and Willson Contreras. Realmuto was a perennial All-Star when he re-upped with the Phillies, and Contreras has been a precious offensive contributor for fairly a while, however McCann solely barely qualifies; he put collectively a pleasant season over 111 plate appearances in 2020. If you happen to’re searching for a star catcher, free company is the mistaken place to set your sights.

This 12 months is far worse than that, although. Neglect three-win catchers; there aren’t any two-win catchers obtainable. Mitch Garver racked up 2.1 WAR, however he’s a DH/catcher hybrid who will probably catch lower than half the time. Gary Sánchez bought DFA’ed by seemingly half the groups in baseball final 12 months, and he’s comfortably the perfect full-time choice behind the plate. Victor Caratini is the next-best choice, and he’s a profession backup who has crossed the 300 plate look threshold precisely as soon as in his profession – he was half a win under substitute stage that 12 months, for what it’s value.

Simply so we’re clear, these are the good choices. Issues get grim after that. Austin Hedges? A 33-year-old Tom Murphy, who has performed 60 video games prior to now two seasons mixed? Mike Zunino, who bought DFA’ed by the notoriously spendthrift Guardians final 12 months? There’s nothing approaching a stable common in that group.

Who’s most affected by this shortfall? The contenders and would-be contenders that didn’t get a lot out of their catchers this 12 months. The Rays, for instance, are counting on a mix of René Pinto and Alex Jackson. They’re no strangers to short-term catcher upgrades, however this offseason doesn’t give them any choices. The Marlins would little question prefer to again up their 2023 playoff run by contending in 2024, however their duo of Nick Fortes and Jacob Stallings doesn’t encourage confidence. They’re caught with it, although, as a result of swapping in Sánchez for Fortes doesn’t change a lot of something.

I depend seven groups with playoff aspirations who’ve questionable catching plans for subsequent 12 months. There are the aforementioned Rays and Marlins, however the get together doesn’t cease there. The Tigers are relying fairly closely on Jake Rogers, and significantly on his newfound receiving expertise, however I’m skeptical that he’ll repeat his profession 12 months, and projection methods are skeptical about his offense. The Crimson Sox are in an identical state of affairs; Connor Wong did an incredible job controlling the operating sport, however his offense and receiving lagged. You’d should have rose coloured glasses to assume he’s the first catcher of the long run there.

The Reds theoretically have Tyler Stephenson as an entrenched starter, however he struggled each offensively and defensively in 2023. He performed plenty of DH to mitigate his defensive shortcomings, however that simply means another catcher should cowl extra plate appearances. The Cubs are a bit higher off than that – Yan Gomes and Miguel Amaya are every nearly as good as any of the choices obtainable in free company – however Steamer tasks them for the Twenty third-most catching WAR.

That leaves maybe the group that would most use some juice from catcher: the Padres. Sánchez gave them a carry final 12 months, however they non-tendered Austin Nola on Friday and Luis Campusano could be extra DH than backstop. That’s nice, as a result of they might use a DH who catches three video games per week, however it’s no shock that the group that may’t cease signing shortstops may actually use a playmaker behind the plate to spherical out their offense. We already know they’re set to commerce gamers to cut back wage, so eradicating a star from the combo will solely exacerbate their want for contributions elsewhere.

These seven groups may all select to focus elsewhere on their roster for offseason enhancements. Nevertheless it’s typically best to enhance the place you’re already weak, and that merely isn’t an choice this 12 months. The tried and true plan of maximizing the expertise you might have in your farm system after which supplementing it in free company doesn’t work when there aren’t any free brokers to cowl your blind spots.

In concept, at the very least, one other manner out of that is by way of commerce. Markets are environment friendly; groups with too many catchers can at all times make trades with catcher-needy groups. You could possibly think about a group with cash to burn and a need to repair the catching place signing an additional starter in free company, then buying and selling an present cost-controlled starter for catching assist. However “groups with too many catchers” are about as widespread as hippogriffs; it’s simply not an actual phenomenon.

The Blue Jays traded their manner out of a catching surplus. The Dodgers have Diego Cartaya ready in Triple-A, however they’re definitely not going to commerce Will Smith to unblock his enjoying time. The Cardinals may make Iván Herrera obtainable – he’s out of minor league choices, and he’s blocked by Contreras – however they could simply as simply resolve to maintain Herrera and provides Contreras extra relaxation days at DH.

One of the best wager for these seven catching-needy groups is to discover a non-contending group keen to commerce a serviceable main league catcher in trade for some cheap bundle of prospects. Only one drawback: that group doesn’t actually exist. The highest 15 groups by way of Steamer projections for catching WAR subsequent 12 months are all playoff groups except the Royals, and the Royals solely seem on that listing due to MJ Melendez, who’s on the catcher depth chart regardless of being an outfielder/DH who solely makes occasional cameos behind the plate. Possibly the Royals would commerce Salvador Perez, however he’s wanting pretty tough behind the plate nowadays; he could be extra of a DH at this level. They may commerce Freddy Fermin, however he’s proper according to what the groups we’re contemplating have already got obtainable.

That leaves precisely one chance for our septet: persuade the Angels to commerce Logan O’Hoppe. The Angels virtually assuredly don’t need to commerce O’Hoppe. At solely 23, he’s considered one of their youngest gamers and likewise considered one of their greatest. They haven’t pivoted totally to a rebuild – Mike Trout continues to be there, in spite of everything – however they’re definitely leaning that manner. Regardless, they definitely put a excessive worth on youth. O’Hoppe manages to suit into each any present desires of relevance and their plans to make things better sooner or later; he gained’t be obtainable for a tune. And it goes even deeper than that; the Angels traded Edgar Quero, their high catching prospect, of their last-gasp pursuit of the playoffs this 12 months. That leaves them skinny at catcher, and it additionally places stress on the Los Angeles entrance workplace to get one thing worthwhile again in the event that they transfer O’Hoppe.

I don’t assume the Marlins, Tigers, or Padres are prone to commerce the Angels what they could be searching for in trade for O’Hoppe. All three of them are the mistaken match. The Marlins have sufficient holes elsewhere that they could as nicely focus there first. O’Hoppe isn’t sufficient of an improve on Rogers to justify Detroit going loopy with the restricted prospects they could look to commerce. The Padres absolutely can’t afford to dip into their farm system any extra; additionally they want pitching so badly that it’s going to take precedence in any commerce choices.

The Cubs have a farm system that’s full to bursting, to the purpose the place they’re in all probability trying to make trades that consolidate worth. However Amaya is a part of that farm system, and he’s roughly the identical age as O’Hoppe. O’Hoppe will fetch lots in commerce as a result of he seems like he might be a beginning catcher for a number of years – however the Cubs have already got that. I believe they’ll look elsewhere – to DH, heart discipline, or starter – in the event that they resolve to commerce for an enormous league roster improve.

The Rays may match the invoice, if solely they weren’t the Rays. I’m not saying there’s no probability they’ll become involved, however buying and selling for a catcher who has already established himself within the majors doesn’t actually match their regular working process. They’ve traditionally prioritized just about each different place once they make offers; as an alternative, they’ve stocked catcher with waiver claims and minor commerce fodder. With different groups, I’d name this a coincidence, however Tampa Bay at all times appears to have a plan, so I believe they’re in all probability out.

That leaves two choices for an O’Hoppe commerce. I’ll begin with the much less probably of the 2. The Reds would dearly like to improve at catcher, and so they have roughly eight trillion infield prospects. There’s absolutely some deal that might look mutually helpful for each them and the Angels. However that doesn’t actually monitor with the way in which the Reds have behaved with their latest core. They haven’t traded to speed up their clock in any respect. They didn’t add on the commerce deadline. They appear to be enjoying the lengthy sport, accumulating small benefits somewhat than taking swings to vary their destiny now. Absolutely there’s some stage of both whole lot or good participant that might change their thoughts, however I doubt that’s in play right here.

That simply leaves the Crimson Sox, and right here I really feel like the 2 sides may discover widespread floor. Boston’s farm system can be wonderful – they’re at the moment second in our farm system rankings behind the Cubs. They like Wong’s throwing, however I believe they’d want to make use of him as a part-time participant somewhat than the on a regular basis starter. They’re fascinated with constructing a sustainable winner, or at the very least they speak a superb sport that manner; meaning O’Hoppe’s youth and contract standing will each enchantment to them. They’ve been related to a number of high free brokers this 12 months, however once more, none of them are catchers; it seems like an ideal time to construct the group by combining spending and buying and selling.

To make sure, they did simply draft a catcher, Kyle Teel, within the first spherical. However catching prospects are notoriously risky, and so they typically take a very long time coming via the system. You possibly can’t deal with a first-round decide like a surefire future a part of your roster; it will be fully cheap so as to add O’Hoppe and maintain Teel, or to make use of them in tandem in some unspecified time in the future sooner or later.

There’s definitely no assure that O’Hoppe is on the market. There’s no assure that the Crimson Sox would have an interest even when he have been, or that the 2 groups would agree on a valuation. However there’s one factor I’m sure of: until you’re buying and selling for him, there’s in all probability no assist at catcher coming on your group this winter.

var SERVER_DATA = Object.assign(SERVER_DATA || {});




Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments